THE MISSING TRANSITION: FROM SINGLE-PARTY TO MULTIPARTY POLITICS

THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN COURAGE AND RECKLESSNESS

BY G. MADARAKA NYERERE

When we rushed to reintroduce multiparty politics in 1992, we began establishing the legal, constitutional and institutional foundations of a liberal democracy but neglected to transform our mindset to embrace its underlying principles. We are now paying the price for that neglect.

At independence, both Tanganyika and Zanzibar had multiparty political systems. In Tanganyika’s pre-independence elections, TANU won 70 of 71 parliamentary seats. The sole exception was Hermangild Sarwatt, who, after his nomination was overturned by TANU’s National Executive Committee, ran as an independent candidate and won. TANU’s landslide victory, coupled with fears that multiparty politics would deepen divisions, helped justify the move to a single-party state in 1965.

In Zanzibar, multiparty politics was suspended following the January 1964 Revolution, leaving the Afro-Shirazi Party (ASP) as the sole political party.

While elections continued in mainland Tanzania under TANU in 1965, 1970 and 1975, Zanzibar held no elections until 1980, following the 1977 merger of TANU and ASP to form Chama Cha Mapinduzi (CCM). In effect, the merger eliminated organised political opposition in both parts of the Union.

Consequently, by the time multiparty politics was reintroduced in 1992, an entire generation of Tanzanians had grown up knowing only the single-party system. Yet, once the constitutional and institutional framework for multiparty politics was established, some appeared to expect these mechanisms alone to produce a seamless transition to the new system.

Recent events suggest that we still have a long way to go before achieving the ideals of a liberal democracy. Some argue that the extreme political polarisation we experience could have been mitigated through genuine commitment to pluralism, independent institutions, constitutional safeguards, civic education, and a level playing field for all parties.

Yet, one critical ingredient has received insufficient attention: a culture of political tolerance across the political spectrum. Tensions, whether fueled by events or the actions of political actors, have increasingly turned politics into a theatre of war, producing winners and losers instead of creating a forum for debate, compromise, and peaceful coexistence.

I am not arguing for or against either system; both have merits and demerits. My argument is that we skipped a crucial learning period that could have prepared Tanzanians for the transition. We assumed that introducing multiparty politics meant everyone automatically understood its principles and responsibilities.

To borrow an aviation analogy, in 1992, after generations on the single-party autopilot, we were expected to transition seamlessly to multiparty politics without adequately learning how to navigate the new system.

Ultimately, democracy requires more than new institutions; it demands a political culture that respects differences, embraces compromise, and recognises the right of others to disagree.

madaraka.nyerere@gmail.com

Support independent journalism in Arusha

Your gift keeps local reporting free and fearless.

Donate now

Advertise with Arusha News

Reach readers across Arusha in print and online.

Advertising options

Get Arusha News in your inbox

The week’s top stories from Arusha, free every Saturday. No spam, unsubscribe any time.